solution

Self-insurance options for retaining risk

Self-insurance is the broad category of risk financing in which an organization retains and pays its own losses instead of transferring them to an insurer for a premium. It sits underneath captives and most other alternative structures, but it does not require forming an insurance company.

Retaining and funding your own losses directly, from deductibles and funded reserves to state-approved programs.

Forms of self-insurance and who oversees them

The form you choose determines who regulates it and which specialists you need. Funding is the discipline that matters most: outside a licensed insurer, no regulator sets a reserve for you.

FormWhat it isOversightMain specialist
Deductible or self-insured retentionYou pay losses up to a level under a conventional policyPolicy terms; no licenseBroker, TPA
Funded reserve or trustMoney set aside against expected claimsInternal governance; trustee if usedActuary, finance
Self-insured workers’ compensationState-approved retention of statutory benefitsState workers’ compensation regulatorTPA, actuary, counsel
Self-funded health planEmployer pays employee health claimsFederal law (ERISA); stop-loss regulated by statesTPA, benefits counsel
CaptiveRetention formalized in a licensed insurerDomicile insurance regulatorCaptive manager, actuary, counsel

Organizations usually move toward a captive when they retain several risk types or jurisdictions, want direct reinsurance access, or need to formalize retention for related entities. Tax treatment differs by form and facts and needs specialist advice. A TPA and an actuary are the usual first engagements.

Benefits and limitations

Potential benefits

  • An organization with better-than-average loss experience can often retain risk for less than a carrier charges.
  • Removes the insurer's expenses and margin from the retained layer.
  • Direct control over claims handling, loss prevention and coverage terms.
  • Informal retention — a deductible, self-insured retention or funded reserve — needs no insurance license.

Key considerations and limitations

  • It needs the balance sheet and tolerance to withstand a bad year.
  • Catastrophic exposure usually still has to be capped with excess or stop-loss cover.
  • Self-insured workers' compensation requires state approval, security and ongoing financial demonstration.
  • Claims have to be administered, commonly through a third-party administrator.

Is this relevant to me?

When it may be worth exploring

  • Losses on the candidate layer are frequent and predictable rather than catastrophic.
  • Your experience is better than the pooled experience the market prices from.
  • You have the scale to absorb volatility without straining cash flow.

When it may not fit

  • The exposure is low-frequency and high-severity, where transfer is usually cheaper.
  • A single bad year would damage the balance sheet.
  • There is no capacity to administer claims or fund them as they fall due.

16 companies

Oct 20, 2026How are these providers ranked?

Not sure where to start?

Not sure whether Self-Insurance is the right route for your risk-financing need? A short structured questionnaire will map your requirements to the right kinds of provider.

Start AI Assessment